Oral Arguments - Wednesday, January 10, 2024 | Appellate Division

Images and video recordings of the Court’s Justices on the Court’s website or otherwise may not be used to advance private interests or in furtherance of any commercial purpose (see Advisory Committee on Judicial Ethics Op. 20-158; see generally 22 NYCRR 100.2 [C], 100.4 [D] [3]).

36
KA 22-00752

PEOPLE
V
RAJZUAN ROUSE

Criminal Possession Weapon

KRISTINE BIALY-VIAU	SUB
BRADLEY W. OASTLER	SUB

37
KA 18-01922

PEOPLE
V
BEUFORD T. RICHARDSON

Course of Sexual Conduct Against a Child

TIMOTHY S. DAVIS	SUB
AMY WALENDZIAK	SUB

PLAY

38
KA 20-01348

PLAY

PEOPLE
V
MALCOLM E. WILLIAMS

Attempted Criminal Possession Controlled Substance

TONYA JEAN PLANK	10
MARTIN P. MCCARTHY, II	10

PLAY

39
KA 22-00394

PLAY

PEOPLE
V
LYDELL C. DILLARD

Sexual Abuse

KATHLEEN P. REARDON	10
MARTIN P. MCCARTHY, II	10

40
KA 22-00746

PEOPLE
V
DWIGHT MOSS

Sentence

DAVID R. JUERGENS	SUB
AMY WALENDZIAK	SUB

PLAY

41
KA 19-01128

PLAY

PEOPLE
V
MAURICE O. MAXON

Criminal Possession Controlled Substance

AXELLE THERESE SOLANGE LECOMTE MATHEWSON	10
KAYLAN C. PORTER	5

42
KA 19-01129

PEOPLE
V
MAURICE O. MAXON

Criminal Possession Controlled Substance

TO BE ARGUED WITH #41

PLAY

43
KA 19-02151

PLAY

PEOPLE
V
CORRY MOORHEAD

Rape

BRADLEY E. KEEM	10
NANCY GILLIGAN	10

44
CA 23-01445

ALBERT G. FRACCOLA
V
1ST CHOICE REALTY

Dismiss Complaint

ALBERT G. FRACCOLA	SUB
PETER M. HOBAICA	SUB
PATRICK G. RADEL	SUB

PLAY

45
CA 23-00635

PLAY

BARRY ESSIG
V
STEVEN F. ESSIG

Damages

KEITH D. MILLER	10
JAMES G. DISTEFANO	15

46
CA 23-00072

CARROLS RESTAURANT GROUP, INC.
V
AMERICAN GUARANTEE AND LIABILITY INSURANCE COMPANY

Dismiss Complaint

GREG GARRELL GUTZLER	SUB
DAVID RUSSELL ROTH	SUB

PLAY

47
OP 23-01347

PLAY

HBC VICTOR LLC
V
TOWN OF VICTOR

Original Proceeding Pursuant to CPLR art 78

CRAIG A. LESLIE	15
KYLE GOOCH	15

PLAY

48
CA 23-00199

PLAY

CONSUMERS BEVERAGES, INC.
V
KAVCON DEVELOPMENT LLC

Disqualify Attorney

TORREY ELIZABETH GRENDA	SUB
JAMES PATRICK MILBRAND	15

PLAY

49
CA 23-00279

PLAY

SARAH ZIELINSKI
V
GEORGE BLESSIOS, M.D.

Summary Judgment

JOHN A. COLLINS	10
MELISSA L. ZITTEL	10

PLAY

50
CA 22-01021

PLAY

KEVIN CONLEY
V
PINELLI LANDSCAPING, INC.

Negligence

EDWARD J. MARKARIAN	15
THOMAS A. DIGATI	15

PLAY

51
CA 23-00972

PLAY

CRYSTAL R. BAKER
V
MCDONALD'S RESTAURANT STORE # 6165

Dismiss Complaint

SCOTT ROGOFF	15
JEFFREY R. PARRY	SUB

52
CA 22-01612

CHARLES E. LORD
V
WHELAN AND CURRY CONSTRUCTION

Personal Injury

SETTLED

PLAY

53
CA 23-00344

PLAY

JAMES A. ZAEPFEL
V
TOWN OF TONAWANDA

Jury Verdict

PAUL G. JOYCE	10
B. KEVIN BURKE, JR.	15

54
CA 23-00440

JAMES A. ZAEPFEL
V
TOWN OF TONAWANDA

Jury Verdict

TO BE ARGUED WITH #53

PLAY

55
CA 23-01188

PLAY

IMAD SALEH
V
245 ONTARIO EXPRESS, INC.

Contract

TODD J. ALDINGER	15
DANIEL J. BOBBETT	15

56
TP 23-01546

DWIGHT VAUGHN
V
ANTHONY ANNUCCI

CPLR art 78 Proceeding Transferred by Order of

NORMAN P. EFFMAN	SUB
DOUGLAS EVELETH WAGNER	SUB

57
TP 23-01548

THEODORE FEDOR
V
PRICILLA LEDBETTER

CPLR art 78 Proceeding Transferred by Order of

ANDREW STECKER	SUB
RACHEL E. RAIMONDI	SUB

RULES FILING FORMS ASSIGNED COUNSEL MOTIONS PERFECTING APPEALS ARGUMENTS DECISIONS NOTICES

ACCESSIBILITY

If you are unable to access the archive of a particular argument because of a disability, please contact Alan Ross, Deputy Clerk of the Court and the Court’s designated ADA Liaison (by e-mail at aross@nycourts.gov or by telephone at 585-530-3102), to request a reasonable accommodation.

Hearing Assistance

ASSISTED LISTENING devices are available in each courtroom during arguments. Please see a court attendant when you enter the courtroom.

CLOSED CAPTIONING is available while viewing archived (not live) oral arguments. Hover your mouse over the video and click the [cc] icon to activate the captions. Please note: these captions are generated by a computer algorithm and are not considered a transcript of the proceedings.

PRIVACY NOTICE

To protect the privacy interests of individuals in matters before the Court, and the need to protect litigants, particularly children, from harm, those persons appearing for oral argument may not disclose:

an individual's social-security number or taxpayer-identification number;
date of an individual's birth;
name of an individual known to be a minor;
or a financial-account number.

Any person responsible for such disclosure at oral argument must report such disclosure to the receptionist immediately following their argument before the Court.

Periodically the court may suspend a broadcast to protect the privacy interests of individuals in matters before the Court.

Wed Jan 10 ArgumentsHon. Samuel L. Green Courtroom

36 KA 22-00752

PEOPLE VRAJZUAN ROUSE

37 KA 18-01922

PEOPLE VBEUFORD T. RICHARDSON

38 KA 20-01348

PEOPLE VMALCOLM E. WILLIAMS

39 KA 22-00394

PEOPLE VLYDELL C. DILLARD

40 KA 22-00746

PEOPLE VDWIGHT MOSS

41 KA 19-01128

PEOPLE VMAURICE O. MAXON

42 KA 19-01129

PEOPLE VMAURICE O. MAXON

TO BE ARGUED WITH #41

43 KA 19-02151

PEOPLE VCORRY MOORHEAD

44 CA 23-01445

ALBERT G. FRACCOLA V1ST CHOICE REALTY

45 CA 23-00635

BARRY ESSIG VSTEVEN F. ESSIG

46 CA 23-00072

CARROLS RESTAURANT GROUP, INC. VAMERICAN GUARANTEE AND LIABILITY INSURANCE COMPANY

47 OP 23-01347

HBC VICTOR LLC VTOWN OF VICTOR

48 CA 23-00199

CONSUMERS BEVERAGES, INC. VKAVCON DEVELOPMENT LLC

49 CA 23-00279

SARAH ZIELINSKI VGEORGE BLESSIOS, M.D.

50 CA 22-01021

KEVIN CONLEY VPINELLI LANDSCAPING, INC.

51 CA 23-00972

CRYSTAL R. BAKER VMCDONALD'S RESTAURANT STORE # 6165

52 CA 22-01612

CHARLES E. LORD VWHELAN AND CURRY CONSTRUCTION

SETTLED

53 CA 23-00344

JAMES A. ZAEPFEL VTOWN OF TONAWANDA

54 CA 23-00440

JAMES A. ZAEPFEL VTOWN OF TONAWANDA

TO BE ARGUED WITH #53

55 CA 23-01188

IMAD SALEH V245 ONTARIO EXPRESS, INC.

56 TP 23-01546

DWIGHT VAUGHN VANTHONY ANNUCCI

57 TP 23-01548

THEODORE FEDOR VPRICILLA LEDBETTER

ACCESSIBILITY

Hearing Assistance

PRIVACY NOTICE

Comment Share your thoughts, comments or suggestions as part of the Court's Excellence Initiative.

Justices of the Court

Clerk of the Court

Programs and Services

The Fourth Department

Attorney Matters

M. Dolores DenmanCourthouse

Appeals & Original Proceedings

Wed Jan 10 Arguments
Hon. Samuel L. Green Courtroom

36
KA 22-00752

PEOPLE
V
RAJZUAN ROUSE

37
KA 18-01922

PEOPLE
V
BEUFORD T. RICHARDSON

38
KA 20-01348

PEOPLE
V
MALCOLM E. WILLIAMS

39
KA 22-00394

PEOPLE
V
LYDELL C. DILLARD

40
KA 22-00746

PEOPLE
V
DWIGHT MOSS

41
KA 19-01128

PEOPLE
V
MAURICE O. MAXON

42
KA 19-01129

PEOPLE
V
MAURICE O. MAXON

43
KA 19-02151

PEOPLE
V
CORRY MOORHEAD

44
CA 23-01445

ALBERT G. FRACCOLA
V
1ST CHOICE REALTY

45
CA 23-00635

BARRY ESSIG
V
STEVEN F. ESSIG

46
CA 23-00072

CARROLS RESTAURANT GROUP, INC.
V
AMERICAN GUARANTEE AND LIABILITY INSURANCE COMPANY

47
OP 23-01347

HBC VICTOR LLC
V
TOWN OF VICTOR

48
CA 23-00199

CONSUMERS BEVERAGES, INC.
V
KAVCON DEVELOPMENT LLC

49
CA 23-00279

SARAH ZIELINSKI
V
GEORGE BLESSIOS, M.D.

50
CA 22-01021

KEVIN CONLEY
V
PINELLI LANDSCAPING, INC.

51
CA 23-00972

CRYSTAL R. BAKER
V
MCDONALD'S RESTAURANT STORE # 6165

52
CA 22-01612

CHARLES E. LORD
V
WHELAN AND CURRY CONSTRUCTION

53
CA 23-00344

JAMES A. ZAEPFEL
V
TOWN OF TONAWANDA

54
CA 23-00440

JAMES A. ZAEPFEL
V
TOWN OF TONAWANDA

55
CA 23-01188

IMAD SALEH
V
245 ONTARIO EXPRESS, INC.

56
TP 23-01546

DWIGHT VAUGHN
V
ANTHONY ANNUCCI

57
TP 23-01548

THEODORE FEDOR
V
PRICILLA LEDBETTER

M. Dolores Denman
Courthouse